Politics · 2019

The House Impeaches Donald Trump on December 18, 2019

The House approved articles of impeachment for abuse of power and obstruction of Congress, making Donald Trump the third impeached US president.

On the calendar

December 18, 2019 was a Wednesday, the 352nd day of 2019 with 13 days left in the year. It fell in ISO week 51.

The House of Representatives impeached President Donald Trump on December 18, 2019. Members approved two articles, one charging abuse of power and the other obstruction of Congress. The votes made Trump the third US president impeached, after Andrew Johnson in 1868 and Bill Clinton in 1998. Richard Nixon resigned in 1974 before the full House voted on articles approved by its Judiciary Committee.

The impeachment vote closed the political year on the 2019 calendar but did not remove Trump from office. Under the Constitution, the House brings charges and the Senate conducts a trial. The Senate acquitted him on February 5, 2020, after neither article received the two-thirds vote required for conviction.

A whistleblower complaint focused attention on Ukraine

The events leading to impeachment centered on US relations with Ukraine. In July 2019, Trump spoke by telephone with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. According to a White House memorandum of the call, Trump asked Zelenskyy to investigate matters involving the 2016 election and former vice president Joe Biden and his son Hunter.

Joe Biden was seeking the Democratic presidential nomination and was a possible opponent in the 2020 election. At the same time, the administration had placed a hold on congressionally appropriated security assistance for Ukraine, which was defending itself against Russian aggression. A sought-after White House meeting for Zelenskyy had also not occurred.

An intelligence-community whistleblower filed a complaint alleging that the president had used his office to seek foreign interference in the election and that officials had restricted access to records of the call. The inspector general considered the complaint urgent and credible, though the acting director of national intelligence initially withheld it from Congress amid legal disagreement.

After public reports and congressional pressure, the administration released the call memorandum and the complaint. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced a formal impeachment inquiry on September 24.

Committees built a factual record through testimony

House committees subpoenaed documents and heard from diplomats, national-security officials and administration employees. Witnesses described an official channel for Ukraine policy and a parallel effort involving Trump’s personal attorney Rudy Giuliani.

US Ambassador to the European Union Gordon Sondland testified that a White House visit was conditioned on Ukraine announcing investigations. Acting ambassador to Ukraine William Taylor described learning that security assistance also depended on public investigations. Other witnesses raised concerns about the call and the removal of Ambassador Marie Yovanovitch.

Trump and his defenders argued that the call was proper, the aid was eventually released, Ukraine announced no investigations and the inquiry was partisan. They also challenged the use of secondhand information in the original complaint and said the president had legitimate concerns about corruption and burden-sharing.

The House Intelligence Committee’s report concluded that Trump solicited foreign interference for personal political benefit and used official acts as leverage. Republicans on the committees disputed that interpretation and argued that the evidence did not support impeachment.

The two articles framed separate constitutional charges

The Judiciary Committee approved two articles that became House Resolution 755. Article I charged abuse of power. It alleged that Trump conditioned official acts—security assistance and a White House meeting—on Ukraine publicly announcing investigations that would benefit his reelection.

The charge was constitutional rather than a count from the federal criminal code. The article argued that using presidential authority to obtain personal political benefit damaged election integrity, national security and the balance of power.

Article II charged obstruction of Congress. It alleged that Trump directed the executive branch not to comply with House subpoenas, causing agencies to withhold documents and officials to refuse testimony. The White House argued that the inquiry was invalid and that the House should have litigated privilege and other disputes.

The House answered that categorical resistance prevented it from carrying out its sole constitutional power of impeachment. The disagreement raised a recurring question: how quickly Congress can obtain information when judicial proceedings may outlast an urgent investigation.

The December 18 votes followed party lines

The House debated the resolution through the day. Supporters described impeachment as necessary to protect constitutional checks and elections. Opponents said the evidence was insufficient, the process unfair and the remedy an attempt to undo the 2016 result.

The House adopted Article I by 230–197, with one member voting present. Two Democrats joined all voting Republicans in opposition. Representative Justin Amash, an independent who had left the Republican Party, voted yes.

Article II passed 229–198, also with one present vote. Three Democrats opposed it, and no Republican supported it. Representative Tulsi Gabbard voted present on both articles. One Democrat who voted against impeachment, Jeff Van Drew, changed his party affiliation to Republican shortly afterward.

Once either article passed, Trump was impeached. The House’s action was complete as an accusation, although Pelosi delayed transmitting the articles and naming managers while seeking clarity about Senate trial procedures.

The Senate trial ended in acquittal

The House delivered the articles to the Senate in January 2020. Chief Justice John Roberts presided, and House managers presented the case against the president. Trump’s lawyers argued for acquittal and attacked both the charges and the House process.

The Senate voted against calling additional witnesses, including former national security adviser John Bolton. Senators then voted on each article on February 5. The abuse-of-power charge received 48 guilty votes and 52 not guilty; Senator Mitt Romney became the first senator to vote to convict a president of his own party. The obstruction charge received 47 guilty votes and 53 not guilty.

Both totals fell far short of the 67 votes required if all 100 senators participate. Trump remained president. Acquittal meant the Senate did not impose removal; it did not reverse the historical fact of House impeachment.

The case shaped later arguments about presidential power

The first Trump impeachment established a record about pressure on a foreign government, congressional access to executive-branch evidence and the use of official power in an election context. Its compressed schedule showed the tension between resolving disputes in court and completing oversight before an election.

Trump was impeached a second time on January 13, 2021, after the attack on the Capitol, making him the only US president impeached twice. The cases involved different events and charges and should not be combined when researching the December 2019 vote.

For calendar readers, the key distinction is straightforward: December 18, 2019, was the House impeachment date; February 5, 2020, was the Senate acquittal date. The full 2019 calendar and 2020 calendar place those stages in their proper years. The process was one constitutional proceeding crossing from one calendar year into the next.

Frequently asked questions

When was Donald Trump first impeached?

The House of Representatives impeached President Donald Trump on Wednesday, December 18, 2019. It approved one article charging abuse of power and another charging obstruction of Congress. The Senate trial began in January 2020 and ended with acquittal on February 5.

Why did the House impeach Trump in 2019?

The first article alleged that Trump abused presidential power by pressuring Ukraine to announce investigations that could help him politically while security assistance and a White House meeting were withheld. The second alleged that he obstructed the House inquiry by directing broad noncompliance with subpoenas for documents and testimony.

What were the House vote totals?

The House adopted the abuse-of-power article by 230 votes to 197, with one member voting present. It adopted the obstruction-of-Congress article by 229 to 198, again with one present vote. The voting was overwhelmingly divided by party, with no Republican supporting either article.

Was Trump removed from office after the 2019 impeachment?

No. Impeachment by the House is a formal accusation, not removal. The Constitution requires a two-thirds Senate vote to convict and remove a president. On February 5, 2020, the Senate acquitted Trump on both articles, so he remained in office.

Sources

  1. List of individuals impeached by the House - US House History
  2. Articles of impeachment, H. Res. 755 - Congress.gov
  3. Trump impeachment and constitutional standards - Constitution Annotated

Facts in this article were checked against the sources above. See our editorial policy to report a correction.